Free for your first official MTD submission: Register Now!Excellent132 reviews onTrustpilot

MTD vs Self Assessment: What Changes, What Stays the Same and Who Still Files a Tax Return

Written byJigyasha KhadkaJigyasha KhadkaJigyasha KhadkaJigyasha KhadkaWritten byJigyasha Khadka is an ACCA student and finance content writer with one year of experience in finance content. Her work focuses on making accounting, finance and UK tax topics easier to understand through clear articles, video scripts and social media content.View profile
Published on: 17 Nov 2026Updated on: 18 Nov 202611 min read
MTD vs Self Assessment

Perhaps HMRC has written to say you must use Making Tax Digital. Perhaps you have read that Self Assessment is ending. Either way, you probably want to know what you have to do differently this year. This guide compares MTD vs Self Assessment for landlords and sole traders, explains who still files a normal return, and shows the transition dates with real figures.

MTD vs Self Assessment at a Glance

The table below compares the two systems side by side for the 2026/27 tax year.

Basis

Self Assessment (no MTD)

MTD for Income Tax

Who uses it

Anyone required to file a return who is not mandated into MTD

Sole traders and landlords with qualifying income over the threshold

Records

Paper or digital, your choice

Digital records in compatible software

Submissions in the year

One tax return

Four quarterly updates per business, plus one tax return

Return deadline (online)

31 January after the tax year

31 January after the tax year

How you file

HMRC online account or software

Compatible software only

Tax payment dates

31 January and 31 July

31 January and 31 July (unchanged)

How much tax you pay

Same rules

Same rules

Is Self Assessment Ending?

No. Self Assessment is the legal framework for reporting income that has not been taxed at source, and it stays in place. Making Tax Digital (MTD) sits on top of it for people above the qualifying income threshold.

The legal foundation for MTD is set out in Section 12C and Schedule A1 to the Taxes Management Act 1970 (TMA 1970), inserted by Section 60 of the Finance (No. 2) Act 2017. The detailed operational requirements were originally set out in The Income Tax (Digital Requirements) Regulations 2021. These were revoked and replaced by The Income Tax (Digital Obligations) Regulations 2026 (S.I. 2026/336), which came into force on 01/04/2026.

What changes is the route. MTD users stop filing the old return through their standard HMRC online account. Instead, they keep digital records, send quarterly updates, and submit their final year-end tax return through HMRC-compatible software.

What HMRC Now Calls the "Tax Return" Under MTD

Early MTD guidance described an End of Period Statement (EOPS) for each business, followed by a "final declaration". HMRC has since removed the End of Period Statement. You now finalise your figures and submit a single tax return through compatible software by 31 January after the tax year. For the 2026/27 tax year, that means by 31/01/2028.

The tax return covers all your income and gains, not only the property and self-employment income in your quarterly updates. Dividends, employment income, pension income and capital gains go in it too. Under MTD, you do not file a separate Self Assessment return for these.

Who Has to Use MTD for Income Tax, and When?

According to GOV.UK, you must use MTD if three conditions apply: you are registered for Self Assessment; you get income from self-employment, property or both; and your qualifying income is over the threshold. HMRC applies the test using your return for an earlier tax year, as the table below shows.

Qualifying income

Tested on your tax return for

MTD starts

Over £50,000

2024/25

06/04/2026

Over £30,000

2025/26

06/04/2027

Over £20,000

2026/27

06/04/2028

What Counts as Qualifying Income

Qualifying income is your total gross income from self-employment and property, before you deduct any expenses. If you are UK resident, it includes UK and foreign property income. Employment income, your share of partnership profits, dividends, savings interest and pensions are left out (GOV.UK: work out your qualifying income).

The test uses turnover, not profit. A landlord with £34,000 of rent and £20,000 of costs on their 2025/26 tax return has a profit of £14,000. Their qualifying income is still £34,000, so they are over the £30,000 threshold and must use MTD from 06/04/2027.

How HMRC Decides Whether You Are In

HMRC looks at the return you have already filed, not your income for the current year. If you stop one income source but keep another, the stopped source can still count for that test year. An amendment made after the MTD tax year has started does not bring you into MTD for that year.

Who Still Files a Self Assessment Tax Return?

HMRC estimates MTD will bring in about 1.75 million sole traders and landlords across its first two phases: around 780,000 from April 2026 and a further 970,000 from April 2027 (GOV.UK). More than 12 million people were expected to file a Self Assessment tax return for 2024/25 (GOV.UK), so most filers will carry on exactly as before. You stay on a Self Assessment tax return if any of the following applies.

Below the Threshold

If your qualifying income is £20,000 or less, MTD has no start date for you under the announced rollout. You keep filing a Self Assessment tax return. You also stay on Self Assessment for now if your income falls between the current and next thresholds. For example, someone with £40,000 of qualifying income in 2024/25 stays on Self Assessment for 2026/27 but must join MTD from 06/04/2027 if their 2025/26 income is over £30,000.

Exempt and Deferred Taxpayers

If HMRC agrees that you are digitally excluded (for example because of age, disability or location), you are exempt. You continue to report your income on a Self Assessment return. At Budget 2026 on 28/10/2026, the government also deferred MTD "until further notice" for some groups (Budget 2026, para 7.15). These include people receiving qualifying care relief (such as foster carers), non-UK resident entertainers and sportspeople, and people expecting to become non-resident, who were already temporarily exempt for 2026/27 under SI 2026/336.

Partnership, PAYE, Dividend and Capital Gains-Only Filers

Partnership profit does not count as qualifying income, so a partner with no other self-employment or property income files a Self Assessment return. The same goes for employees with untaxed income, company directors paid through dividends, and anyone reporting only a capital gain, provided they have no self-employment or property income.

Your Last Self Assessment Return Before MTD Starts

In the year MTD starts, you still file a Self Assessment return for the previous year. If you joined MTD on 06/04/2026, your 2025/26 Self Assessment return is due by 31/01/2027. This deadline falls in the same period as your first MTD quarterly updates for 2026/27.

Opting Out After Three Years Below the Threshold

You can leave MTD if your qualifying income stays below the threshold for three tax years in a row. Until then, you stay in MTD, even if your income falls below the threshold for a single year.

What Changes Under MTD?

If you are in MTD, three things change: how you keep records, how often you report, and how late submissions are penalised.

Digital Records and Compatible Software

You must keep a digital record of each income and expense transaction: the date, the amount and the category. A shoebox of receipts that you total in March is no longer enough. Spreadsheets are allowed only if bridging software links them to HMRC without retyping figures (GOV.UK: keep digital records).

Quarterly Updates Are Cumulative

You send one update per business per quarter. A UK property business, a foreign property business and each self-employed trade are separate businesses. With standard update periods, the deadlines for 2026/27 are 07/08/2026, 07/11/2026, 07/02/2027 and 07/05/2027.

Each update is cumulative. It shows your year-to-date totals from 6 April, not just the latest three months. If you find an error in the first quarter, you correct it in the next update instead of resubmitting. If your accounts run from 1 April to 31 March, you can choose calendar update periods (quarters ending 30 June, 30 September, 31 December and 31 March) instead of the standard periods ending on the 5th. You must choose before your first update, and you cannot switch for the rest of that tax year (GOV.UK: send quarterly updates).

Penalty Points and the Soft Landing

MTD uses a points-based system for late submissions under Schedule 24 to the Finance Act 2021. You get one point for each missed quarterly update deadline, and a £200 penalty once you reach four points. HMRC will not apply penalty points for late quarterly updates during the 2026/27 tax year (GOV.UK: penalties).

At Budget 2026, the government announced that people joining in April 2027 would not receive penalty points for their first four quarterly updates in 2027/28 (Budget 2026). The soft landing covers quarterly updates only. Late tax returns and late payment can still be penalised.

Note

The soft landing does not mean the updates are optional. You still have to send all four quarterly updates for each business before HMRC accepts your tax return.

What Stays the Same?

Most of what decides your tax bill is unchanged. Tax rates, the personal allowance, the property and trading allowances, allowable expenses and finance cost relief for residential landlords all work exactly as before.

The payment calendar is also the same. Your balancing payment and first payment on account are due on 31 January, and your second payment on account is due on 31 July. You keep your Unique Taxpayer Reference (UTR), and an accountant or agent can still act for you.

MTD vs Self Assessment for Landlords: How It Works

Some MTD rules apply only to landlords, and sole-trader guides rarely cover them.

UK Property: One Business, However Many Properties

All your UK lettings form one UK property business. Three buy-to-lets mean one quarterly update each quarter, not three. You still need digital records for each property so the figures add up.

Foreign Property: A Separate Business With Its Own Updates

If you are UK resident, overseas rent counts towards qualifying income and forms a separate foreign property business. That means a second set of quarterly updates. Read more on our UK and foreign property page.

Jointly Owned Property

Only your share counts. GOV.UK's own example is £50,000 of rent shared equally, which gives each owner £25,000 of qualifying income. If your agent or co-owner gives you only your net share after expenses, HMRC uses that net figure.

For jointly let property, the quarterly updates can show income only, and less detailed records are allowed. You add the expenses before you submit your tax return. Any property you own alone still needs income and expenses in every update. Our guide to MTD for jointly owned properties covers this in detail.

Joint owners are tested separately, so one co-owner can be mandated into MTD while the other is not.

Landlords Who Are Also Sole Traders

Your rental income and self-employment turnover are added together for the threshold. You then send separate quarterly updates for each business, and one tax return brings everything together.

Non-Resident Landlords

If you are not UK resident, only your UK property income and any UK self-employment count towards qualifying income. Foreign rent is left out of the test. MTD reporting is separate from the Non-Resident Landlord Scheme, which deals with tax deducted from rent by agents or tenants.

Worked Examples

Worked Example 1: Joint Owners Crossing £30,000 in 2027

Priya and Tom own three flats 50/50. Their total gross rent in 2025/26 is £70,000.

Item

Priya

Tom

Share of gross rent

£35,000

£35,000

Other self-employment

£0

£0

Qualifying income (2025/26)

£35,000

£35,000

Over £30,000?

Yes

Yes

MTD starts

06/04/2027

06/04/2027

If the gross rent had been £56,000, each share would be £28,000. Neither would join in April 2027, but both would be tested again against £20,000 on their 2026/27 returns.

Worked Example 2: Landlord and Sole Trader With £52,000 Combined

Sam has £25,000 of rent and £27,000 of self-employment turnover in 2024/25.

Item

Figure

UK property income

£25,000

Self-employment turnover

£27,000

Qualifying income

£52,000

MTD starts

06/04/2026

Quarterly updates in 2026/27

8 (4 for property, 4 for self-employment)

Tax returns for 2026/27

1, due 31/01/2028

Neither income source is over £50,000 on its own, but the combined figure is.

Worked Example 3: The Transition Year Calendar

This is Sam's calendar for the first year of MTD.

Date

What is due

07/08/2026

First MTD quarterly update (06/04/2026 to 05/07/2026)

07/11/2026

Second quarterly update

31/01/2027

2025/26 Self Assessment return and payment (old system)

07/02/2027

Third quarterly update

07/05/2027

Fourth quarterly update

31/07/2027

Second payment on account

31/01/2028

2026/27 tax return through MTD software, and payment

Disclaimer

These figures are illustrative. Your own position depends on your specific income and expenses.

Common Mistakes in MTD vs Self Assessment

Mistake

Better approach

Testing the threshold on profit

Use gross rent and turnover before expenses

Counting the whole joint rent

Count only your own share

Thinking MTD means quarterly tax payments

Payment dates stay 31 January and 31 July

Forgetting the last Self Assessment return

File the year before MTD on the old system

Planning to file an End of Period Statement

It was removed; file one tax return through software

Leaving foreign rent out of the test (UK residents)

Add it to qualifying income

What to Do Next

1
Check your qualifying income.
Add gross rent (your share) and turnover from your last filed return. Our MTD checker can help.
2
Find your start date.
Compare your figure with the £50,000, £30,000 and £20,000 thresholds.
3
Sign up for MTD.
Check whether HMRC has signed you up. If not, sign up before your start date.
4
Choose your update periods.
Decide between standard and calendar quarters before your first update.
5
Move your records into software.
Record each transaction as it happens, not at year end.
6
Keep your last return on track.
File the previous year's Self Assessment return by 31 January as normal.

Conclusion

The MTD vs Self Assessment question is really about which route your return takes. If your qualifying income is over the threshold, you report more often and through software, but you pay the same tax on the same dates. If it is not, nothing changes yet. In practice, the landlords who struggle are usually the ones who leave a year of rent and repairs until January. Keeping records each month turns each quarterly update into a short check rather than a scramble. If you want that monthly habit without a spreadsheet, the next step is below.

See how RentalBux handles your MTD filing end-to-end

Simplify quarterly filings, MTD Compliance and Property Management. See how RentalBux helps you stay organised and compliant.

Support

FAQ Section

4 answers · curated
Do HMRC Check Every Self Assessment Return?

HMRC does not review every return by hand, but its systems check each one for errors and inconsistencies when you submit it. HMRC can also open a compliance check into a return, normally within 12 months of receiving it if you filed on time. Keep your property and business records for at least five years after the 31 January deadline.

What Is the Difference Between Self Assessment Tax and Payments on Account?

Self Assessment is the system for reporting and paying tax on income that has not been taxed at source. Payments on account are advance payments towards next year's bill: two instalments, each half of last year's bill, due on 31 January and 31 July. They do not apply if your last bill was under £1,000 or more than 80% of your tax was collected at source. MTD does not change them.

What Is Changing With MTD?

If your qualifying income is over the threshold, you keep digital records, send four quarterly updates for each property or self-employment business, and file your tax return through compatible software by 31 January. The tax you pay, the rates and the payment dates stay the same. The thresholds are over £50,000 from 06/04/2026, over £30,000 from 06/04/2027 and over £20,000 from 06/04/2028.

What Are the Key Changes to Income Tax Rules for Landlords in 2026?

The main change in 2026 is MTD for Income Tax, which started on 06/04/2026 for landlords and sole traders with qualifying income over £50,000. If you are in it, you now keep digital records and send quarterly updates. HMRC will not apply penalty points for late quarterly updates in 2026/27, but the tax return and payment deadlines still apply.

Liked this article?

Leave a 30-second Trustpilot review — it keeps us writing.

Found this useful?

Share or cite this article

Copy a ready-made link or markdown snippet to share this article with others.

HTML
<a href="https://rentalbux.com/blogs/mtd-vs-self-assessment">MTD vs Self Assessment: What Changes, What Stays the Same and Who Still Files a Tax Return — RentalBux</a>
Markdown
[MTD vs Self Assessment: What Changes, What Stays the Same and Who Still Files a Tax Return — RentalBux](https://rentalbux.com/blogs/mtd-vs-self-assessment)

See how RentalBux handles your MTD filing end-to-end

Property, self-employment and foreign lets in one submission. No per-filing fees.

About the author